>>> GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE. THE
FEBRUARY 22nd, 2023 MEETING OF
THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND
TECHNOLOGY AND CITY LIGHT
MEETING IS ABOUT TO COME TO
ORDER. IT IS 9:32. I'M SARA
NELSON, CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE.
COUNCIL PRESIDENT JUAREZ HAS
ASKED TO BE EXCUSED, AND
COUNCILMEMBER SAWANT'S OFFICE
SAID SHE CAN NOT BE HERE EITHER
SO SHE IS EXCUSED.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS, HERE.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD HERE.
THERE ARE THREE PRESENT.
>> THREE REAPPOINTMENTS TO
SEATTLE'S COMMUNITY TECHNOLOGY
ADVISORY BOARD, OR C TAB, WHICH
ADDRESSES ISSUES OF
COMMUNITYWIDE INTEREST RELATING
TO INFORMATION AND
COMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY. THEN
WE HAVE A BRIEFING DISCUSSION,
AND POSSIBLE VOTE ON SIX GROUP
SURVEILLANCE IMPACT REPORTS FOR
TECHNOLOGIES OR DEVICES THAT TH
SEATTLE APPELLATE CURRENTLY
USES. THESE INCLUDE CAMERA
SYSTEMS FOR IMAGES OR
NONAUDITORY VIDEO RECORDINGS.
VEHICLE CRASH DATA RETRIEVAL
TOOLS, COMPUTER CELL PHONE, AND
MOBILE DEVICE DATA EXTRACTION
TOOLS, GEOTIME SOFTWARE, AND
TRACKING DEVICES. ARE THERE ANY
OBJECTIONS TO THE AGENDA? SEEIN
NONE, THE AGENDA IS ADOPTED.
WITH THAT, WE'LL MOVE INTO
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE ITEMS
LISTED ON THE AGENDA. YOU MAY
ROLL THE NEW VIDEO, PLEASE.
>> HELLO, SEATTLE. WE ARE THE
EMERALD CITY. THE CITY OF
FLOWERS AND THE CITY OF
GOODWILL, BUILT ON INDIGENOUS
LAND, THE TRADITIONAL TERRITORY
OF THE COAST SAILORS PEOPLES.
SEATTLE IS EAGER TO HEAR FROM
RESIDENTS OF OUR CITY. IF YOU
WOULD LIKE TO BE A SPEAKER AND
PROVIDE A VERBAL PUBLIC COMMENT
YOU MAY REGISTER TWO HOURS PRIO
TO THE MEETING VIA THE SEATTLE
CITY COUNCIL WEBSITE. SPEAKERS
ARE CALLED UPON IN THE ORDER IN
WHICH THEY WERE REGISTERED. EAC
SPEAKER MUST CALL IN FROM THE
PHONE NUMBER PROVIDED WHEN THEY
REGISTERED ONLINE, AND USE THE
MEETING ID AND PASS CODE THAT
WAS EMAILED UPON CONFIRMATION.
IF YOU DID NOT RECEIVE AN EMAIL
CONFIRMATION, PLEASE CHECK YOUR
SPAM OR JUNK MAIL FOLDERS. A
REMINDER, THE SPEAKER MEETING I
IS DIFFERENT FROM THE GENERAL
LISTENING LINE PROVIDED ON THE
AGENDA. ONCE A SPEAKER'S NAME I
CALLED, THE SPEAKER'S MICROPHON
WILL BE UNMUTED, AND A PROMPT
WILL SAY THE HOST WOULD LIKE YO
TO UNMUTE YOUR MICROPHONE. THAT
IS YOUR PROPRIETOR THIS IT'S
YOUR TURN TO SPEAK. AT THAT
TIME, YOU MUST PRESS STAR 6. YO
WILL HEAR A PROMPT OF YOU ARE
UNMUTED. AS A SPEAKER YOU SHOUL
BEGIN BY STATING YOUR NAME AND
THE ITEM THAT YOU ARE
ADDRESSING. A CHIME WILL SOUND
WHEN THERE ARE 10 SECONDS LEFT
IN YOUR ALLOTTED TIME AS A
GENTER REMINDER TO WRAP UP
PUBLIC COMMENTS. AT THE TIME OF
YOUR TIME, YOUR MICROPHONE WILL
BE MUTED AND THE NEXT SPEAKER
WILL BE CALLED. THEN PLEASE
DISCONNECT FROM THE PUBLIC
COMMENT LINE AND JOIN US VIA
FOLLOWING THE MEETING VIA THE
SEATTLE PUBLIC CHANNEL BROADCAS
OR THE LISTENING LINE LISTED ON
THE AGENDA. THE COUNCIL RESERVE
THE RIGHT TO ELIMINATE PUBLIC
COMMENT IF THE SYSTEM IS BEING
ABUSED, OR IF IT APPEASES THE
ABILITY TO CONDUCT BUSINESS ON
BEHALF OF THE RESIDENTS OF THE
CITY. ANY OFFENSIVE LANGUAGE
THAT IS DISRUPTIVE TO THESE
PROCEEDINGS OR IS NOT FOCUSED O
A SPECIFIC TOPIC MAY LEAD TO TH
SPEAKER BEING MUTE BY THE
PROVIDING OFFICER. OUR GOAL IS
TO ASSIST OUR ORDERLY RELATIONS
OF ISSUES BEFORE THE COUNCIL.
THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD IS NO
OPEN. AND WE WILL BEGIN WITH TH
FIRST SPEAKER ON THE LIST.
PLEASE REMEMBER TO PRESS STAR 6
AFTER YOU HEAR THE PROMPT OF YO
HAVE BEEN UNMUTED. THANK YOU,
SEATTLE.
>> ALL RIGHT, WE HAVE NO ONE
HERE IN CHAMBERS TO SPEAK
PUBLICLY, AND THERE IS ONE
PERSON SIGNED UP ONLINE. SO
WE'LL PROCEED WITH OUR ONE
ONLINE COMMENTER, AND YOU WILL
HAVE TWO MINUTES, AND I WILL NO
CALL CYNTHIA SPIES. GO AHEAD,
PLEASE.
>> HI. I'M CYNTHIA SPEOS, SPES
THANK YOU, COUNCILMEMBER HERBOL
FOR PROPOSING AMENDS. I SUPPORT
ALL OF THEM. PLEASE ALSO SUBMIT
AMENDMENTS SINCE MINE AND MANY
OTHERS HAVE NOT BEEN
INCORPORATED. THERE SHOULD BE
PROHIBITED FROM MISDEMEANOR
OFFICIALS. THE USE OF THESE
TOOLS SHOULD NOT BE BASED ON
SPD'S FLUCTUATING STAFFING.
THEIR USE SHOULD BE PROPORTIONA
TO THE CRIME. WHILE THE PROPOSE
AMENDS ARE THE BOLSTERING OF
THIS RIGHTS ACT, THE RISK OF
COURSE IS GREAT TO ALLOW ANYONE
TO CONSENT TO SEARCH E.SUCH A
SEARCH WITHOUT COUNCIL. THIS IS
ESPECIALLY TRUE FOR THE
COMPUTER, CELL PHONE, AND MOBIL
DISTRACTION DEVICE, BECAUSE IT'
SHOWN THE GENERAL PUBLIC IS NOT
AWARE OF THE DATA ON THOSE
PHONES, NOR THE RAMIFICATIONS O
LONG TERM STORAGE. A RANDOM
PERSON WOULD NOT ACCURATELY
JUDGE THE RISK. AS SUCH LEGAL
COUNCIL SHOULD BE REQUIRED TO
CONSENT. ACROSS THE BOARD BE
THERE SHOULD BE A BAN ON
POLICING AND BIOMETRIC TOOLS
SUCH AS FACE, GATE, OR VOICE
ANALYSIS. FOR UNDERCAMERA
CAMERAS AND LOCATION TRACKERS,
COUNCIL SHOULD SAY IT EXPOSES
THE INDIVIDUAL TO CRIMINAL OR
CIVIL LIABILITY. THERE'S A
POTENTIAL FOR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
SITUATIONS WHERE AN UNETHICAL
SPD EMPLOYEE USES THESE FOR
PERSONAL USE. THE SEATTLE
SURVEILLANCE ORGANIZATION
DOESN'T ADDRESS INDIVIDUAL CITY
EMPLOYEES ACTING OUTSIDE THE
SCOPE OF THE ORDINANCE. SPD IS
USING AT LEAST ONE TOOL WHICH I
LINKED TO HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES I
MULTIAUTHORITARIAN COUNTRIES. I
URGE COUNCILMEMBERS TO REVIEW
THE EMAILS I HAVE SENT, WHICH
INCLUDE DETAILED
RECOMMENDATIONS. THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THAT'S
IT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT. IT'S NOW
CLOSED. WILL THE CLERK PLEASE
READ ITEMS ONE THROUGH NINE INT
THE RECORD? BECAUSE WE HAVE SIX
APPOINTMENTS AND THREE
REAPPOINTMENTS, SO WE'LL JUST
ALL READ THEM IN ALL AT ONCE.
>> AGENDA ITEM 1. APPOINTMENT
02474. POINT MUCH AISHAH
BOMANI. AGENDA ITEM 2,
APPOINTMENT 02470. APPOINTMENT
OF COLEMAN ENTRINGER FOR A TER
TO DECEMBER 31st , 2023. AGENDA
ITEM 3, APPOINTMENT 02475.
APPOINTMENT OF PHILLIP MENG FOR
A TERM TO DECEMBER 31st, 2024.
APPOINTMENT OF MERRILL MILLER A
MEMBER OF THE COMMUNITY
TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY BOARD FOR A
TERM TO DECEMBER 31, 2024.
AGENDA ITEM 5. APPOINTMENT
02473. POINT OF ISABELLA
RODRIGUEZ. APPOINTMENT OF OMARI
STRINGER AS MEMBER OF THE
COMMUNITY TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY
BOARD FOR A TERM TO DECEMBER 31
2024. AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 7.
APPOINTMENT 02478. REAPPOINTMEN
OF FEMI ADD BUYO AS MEMBER OF
THE COMMUNITY TECHNOLOGY
ADVISORY BOARD FOR A TERM TO
DECEMBER 31, 2024. APPOINTMENT
02471. REAPPOINTMENT OF DR.
GRANDERSON FOR A TERM TO
DECEMBER 31, 2023. AGENDA NUMBE
ITEM 9. REAPPEAL OF CAMILLE
ALONSO FOR A TERM TO DECEMBER
31, 2023. ALL NINE ITEMS UP FOR
BRIEFING, DISCUSSION, AND
POSSIBLE VOTE.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'VE
GOT JOHN MORE MORRISON WINTERS
FROM SEATTLE I.T. WHO IS COMING
TO THE TABLE TO PRESENT ON THES
APPOINTMENTS, AND
REAPPOINTMENTS. AND I MUST SAY,
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR BEING
HERE IN PERSON. I APPRECIATE IT
WE'VE ALSO GOT VIN ON THE LINE
FROM SEATTLE I.T., AND ELEANOR
BOUNDS AND SARA CARRIER AS WELL
SO THE WAY THIS WILL GO IS YOU
WILL PRESENT JON, THE PURPOSE O
C TAB, AND THEN WE'LL PROCEED
WITH SOME INTRODUCTIONS. FOLKS
THAT ARE NEW APPOINTMENTS. GO
AHEAD.
>> VERY GOOD. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. THANK YOU COMMITTEE CHAIR
NELSON AND COMMUNITY MEMBERS FO
INVIOLATING ME TO JOIN YOU
TODAY. I'M JOHN MORRISON
WINTERS, THE DIGITAL EQUITY
PROGRAM AND MANAGER AT SEATTLE
I.T. ON BEHALF OF SEATTLE I.T.,
I'M PLEASED TO PRESENT TO
COUNCIL THE APPOINTMENT FILES
FOR SIX NEW MEMBERS TO THE
COMMUNITY TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY
BOARD, OR C TAB. C TAB IS A TEN
MEMBER BOARD THAT WAS
ESTABLISHED IN 1995, AND REVISE
IN 2015. SIX MEMBERS ARE
APPOINTED BY THE MAYOR, AND FOU
ARE APPOINTED BY THE COUNCIL. C
TAB'S FUNCTION IS TO HELP GUIDE
CITY STRATEGIES ON TECHNOLOGY
ISSUES AND PROMOTE ACCESS TO
TECHNOLOGY. C TAB ADVISES
SEATTLE I.T., THE MAYOR, AND TH
CITY COUNCIL ON A RANGE OF
ISSUES, INCLUDING BROADBAND
POLICY, COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT,
SMALL CELL WIRELESS DEPLOYMENT
AND ACCESS TO TECHNOLOGY FOR
STUDENTS, FAMILIES, AND
UNDERSERVED RESIDENTS. AT THE
END OF 2022, DUE TO SOME MEMBER
DEPARTING EARLY, AND OTHER
MEMBERS COMPLETING THEIR SECOND
TERMS, WE HAD SIX OPENING TO
FILL. IN NOVEMBER, WE PROMOTED
THE BOARD OPENINGS AND ASKED TH
PUBLIC TO APPLY TO C TAB. IN
TOTAL WE RECEIVED OVER 20
APPLICATIONS, AND AMONG THAT
TOOL WE CONDUCTED 12 INTERVIEWS
THE INTERVIEW PANEL INCLUDED
STAFF FROM COUNCILMEMBER
NELSON'S OFFICE, THE MAYOR'S
OFFICE, AND SEATTLE I.T. IT
INCLUDED SKILLS AND WILLINGNESS
TO COMMIT THEIR TIME TO THE
BOARD. WE ALSO CONSIDERED
DIVERSITY OF VIEWPOINT AND
REPRESENTATION. SEATTLE I.T. IS
REALLY EXCITED ABOUT THIS
INCREDIBLE GROUP OF NEW
APPOINTEES, AND WE LOOK FORWARD
TO WORKING WITH THE NEW BOARD.
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY T
PRESENT THEM TO YOU TODAY.
>> THANK YOU, JON. JUST A
QUESTION. AFTER TODAY, WILL ALL
THE POSITIONS BE FILLED?
>> YEAH, THAT'S CORRECT. WE'LL
HAVE A FULL CONTINGENCY AFTER
TODAY.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THAT IS
A LOT OF WORK TO KEEP A
COMMISSIONFUL. SO GOOD WORK WIT
THAT LIFT LAST YEAR. HERE'S HOW
WE'LL GO. I'M GOING TO ASK EACH
PERSON TO INTRODUCE CAN
THEMSELVES BRIEFLY, AND I'M
GOING TO START WITH COLEMAN
BECAUSE OF YOUR TIME
CONSTRAINTS. SO WHY DON'T YOU
TELL US A LITTLE ABOUT YOURSELF
COLEMAN.
>> HI EVERYONE, I'M COLEMAN
ENTRINGER, I'VE HAD THE PLEASUR
OF SERVING WITH C TAB ON A MORE
INFORMAL BASIS FOR THE PAST TWO
YEARS AS A COCHAIR OF THE
DIGITAL EQUITY COMMUNITY. IN MY
PROFESSIONAL LIFE, I'M A
CORPORATE STRATEGY CONSULTANT,
WHERE I PRIMARILY SERVE LARGE
TECH COMPANIES BASED ON THE WES
COAST ACROSS A RANGE OF ISSUES,
BUT PRIMARILY ACCESS
ACCESSIBILITY OF TECHNOLOGY
PRODUCTS. AND TECHNOLOGY COMPAN
STAFFING. I'M REALLY EXCITED TO
POTENTIALLY JOIN C TAB AND TO
HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
CONTINUE, TO PROMOTE THE USE OF
TECHNOLOGY TO IMPROVE THE LIVES
OF THE RESIDENTS OF SEATTLE. SO
HAPPY TO BE HERE.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, AND
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
WILLINGNESS TO SERVE, AND FOR
YOUR PAST WORK AS COCHAIR ON A
VOLUNTEER BASIS AS WELL.
>> ALL RIGHT. AISHAH, ARE YOU
HERE?
>> GOOD MORNING. YES, MY NAME I
AISHAH BOMANI. I'M REALLY
EXCITED ABOUT THIS APPOINTMENT.
I'VE BEEN DOING THIS WORK FOR
ABOUT THREE YEARS NOW. THAT
PROGRAM CAME OUT OF COVID-19
WITH THE NEED TO SERVE OUR
STUDENTS AND FAMILIES WITH MORE
EXPEDITED TECH SUPPORT AND
EQUITY TO MAKE SURE ALL FAMILIE
ARE HAVING ACCESS TO TECHNOLOGY
DURING THAT TIME. WE'RE ALL ON
SCREEN, RIGHT? BEYOND THAT, I'M
BORN AND RAISED HERE IN SEATTLE
REALLY LOOKING FORWARD TO
SERVING MY COMMUNITY IN A MORE
WIDER SENSE. NOT JUST WITH THE
SCHOOLS. I'VE BEEN WORKING WITH
DAVID KEYS SINCE MY -- FOR ABOU
THREE YEARS NOW. SO I'M REALLY
EXCITED TO WORK WITH HIM ON THI
LEVEL. AND YEAH, HAPPY TO BE
HERE.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THAT
MUST HAVE BEEN DIFFICULT WORKIN
DURING THAT TIME PERIOD. ALL
RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
YOUR WILLINGNESS TO SERVE AS
WELL. AND PHILLIP. GOOD MORNING
>> GOOD MORNING. THANK YOU CHAI
NELSON, THANK YOU
COUNCILMEMBERS. I STUDY
INFORMATION SYSTEMS, FINANCE,
AND GLOBAL STUDIES AT THE
UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON AND I
CURRENTLY WORK AS A YOUNG GLOBA
PROFESSIONAL. I'M REALLY
GRATEFUL TO BE CONSIDERED FOR
THE COMMUNITY TECHNOLOGY
ADVISORY BOARD. HAD FIRST BECOM
INVOLVED AS ON ITS DIGITAL
EQUITY COMMITTEE. AS PART OF TH
COMMITTEE LAST YEAR, I BUILT
RESOURCES BASED ON OUR TELECOM
FORUM. AND IF CONFIRMED TO THE
BOARD, I REALLY HOPE TO CONTINU
THIS FOCUS ON ACCESS TO
TECHNOLOGY, AND DIGITAL EQUITY.
TO THE BOARD, I HOPE TO BRING
PERSPECTIVE. I PREVIOUSLY WORKE
AT QUALTRIX AND RESEARCHED SOME
TECHNOLOGY POLICY ISSUES LIKE
CRYPTOCURRENCIES. SO I
APPRECIATE YOUR TIME AND
CONSIDERATION TODAY.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I NOTIC
THAT YOU WILL BE GRADUATING THI
YEAR WITH A TRIPLE MAJOR IN
INFORMATION SYSTEMS FINANCE AND
GLOBAL AND REGIONAL STUDIES FRO
U DUB. AWESOME.
>> A MOUTHFUL.
>> CONGRATULATIONS IN ADVANCE.
>> THANK YOU.
>> SO FAR, ALL THE FOLKS THAT
WE'VE BEEN INTRODUCING ARE
MAYORAL APPOINTMENTS. MAYORAL,
YOU ARE OUR FIRST COUNCIL
APPOINTMENT. WILL YOU PLEASE
INTRODUCE YOURSELF?
>> THANK YOU. MY NAME IS MERRIL
MILLER. I'M BORN AND RAISED IN
THE SEATTLE COMMUNITY AND HAVE
RETURNED AFTER SOME YEARS ON TH
EAST COAST. I'M CURRENTLY HEAD
OF BUSINESS OPERATION FOR
GOOGLE'S CYBERSECURITY ACTION
TEAM WHO'S MISSION IS TO SECURE
OUR CLOUD CUSTOMERS AND THE
WORLD. SO I'M EXCITED TO BRING
MY STRATEGY PROGRAM AND PROJECT
MANAGEMENT IN CYBERSECURITY
EXPERTISE TO THE BOARD.
>> THANK YOU. YOU CAUGHT MY
ATTENTION BECAUSE YOU'VE DONE
SECURITY IN EVERY LINE OF YOUR
PAST PROFESSIONAL WORK AT
GEMINI, GOLDMAN SACHS, ET
CETERA. SO I APPRECIATE THAT
FOCUS THAT YOU BRING TO THE
COMMITTEE.
>> THANK YOU.
>> OR TO THE COMMISSION. THANK
YOU FOR YOUR WILLINGNESS TO
SERVE. AND ISABEL, PLEASE
INTRODUCE YOURSELF. YOU ARE A
MAYORAL APPOINTMENT.
>> I AM. THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE THIS
MORNING. MY NAME IS ISABEL
RODRIGUEZ. I'M A RESEARCH
ANALYST AND COMMUNICATIONS
PROFESSIONAL, WORKS AT THE
INTERSECTION OF TECHNOLOGY AND
SOCIETY. I RECEIVED BOTH OF MY
BACHELORS AND MASTERS IN PHYSIC
AND I CURRENTLY WORK IN A
NON-PROFIT SPACE. WHEN I FIRST
CAME ACROSS C TAB I WAS REALLY
LOOKING FOR INITIATIVES IN
SEATTLE THAT VALUE COMMUNITY
ENGAGEMENT, AND THAT LEVERAGED
THE VOICES OF ITS RESIDENTS TO
INFLUENCE TECHNICAL DECISION
MAKING AT THE LEVEL OF
GOVERNMENT AND SO AFTER, YOU
KNOW, ATTENDING MEETINGS JUST A
A COMMUNITY MEMBER AT THE END O
THE YEAR, I STEPPED INTO A
COCHAIR ROLE FOR C TAB'S PRIVAT
SECURITY SUBCOMMITTEE. COMING
INTO C TAB PROPER, I WOULD BE
DOING SO WITH AN INTEREST TO
EXPLORE ALGORITHMS AND A.I. AN
I LOOK FORWARD TO EXPANDING OUR
OUTREACH EFFORTS. THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU. AND LET'S SEE,
FINALLY, OMARI. YOU LOOK
FAMILIAR. JUST KIDDING. YOU ARE
THE OTHER COUNCIL APPOINTEE, AN
CAN YOU PLEASE INTRODUCE
YOURSELF?
>> HI FOLKS. AS YOU MENTIONED I
MIGHT BE A FAMILIAR FACE TO SOM
OF YOU. I GOT EXPOSED TO C TAB
PRIMARILY AS AN EMPLOYEE OF THE
SEATTLE I.T. DEPARTMENT. IT'S
NICE TO BE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF
IT, AND CERTAINLY WANT TO
CONTINUE PARTICIPATING IN KIND
OF THE CIVILLIC TECHNOLOGY SPAC
AND CONTRIBUTING MY SKILLS TO
SEATTLE AT LARGE. SO I'M VERY
EXCITED FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY AN
THIS APPOINTMENT. AND YOU KNOW,
CONTINUING TO WRING SOME OF THE
EXPERIENCE FOR THE PRIVATE
SECTOR INTO, YOU KNOW, ADVISING
YOU KNOW, THE PUBLIC SECTOR,
SEATTLE I.T. COUNCIL AND THE
MAYOR ON ISSUES. WE HAVE HAD
SOME UP FOR REVIEW THIS
COMMITTEE MEETING. IT'S FIND OF
FUN, I MIGHT LISTEN TO IT AS A
MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC, INSTEAD O
BEING ON THE OTHER SIDE. BUT I
JUST WANTED TO GIVE A SHOUT OUT
TO MY SEATTLE I.T. COLLEAGUES
AND I APPRECIATE THE WORK THAT
YOU GUYS DO, AND APPRECIATE
LOOKING FORWARD TO CONTINUING T
WORKING WITH YOU.
>> THANK YOU, OMARI. I WAS BEIN
SARCASTIC, OF COURSE, YOU HAVE
PROCESSED THE SURVEILLANCE
REPORTS FOR YEARS, AND I'M SURE
THAT WE ALL MISS YOU. I KNOW I
CERTAINLY DO, AND THAT WILL BE
THE SECOND PART OF OUR COMMUNIT
MEETING TODAY. DO MY COLLEAGUES
HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
OF OUR APPOINTMENTS? OKAY. THAN
YOU AGAIN, EVERYONE. EXCUSE ME.
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> I JUST WANTED TO ECHO YOUR
THANKS TO THE APPOINTEES. I
APPRECIATE EVERYBODY'S
WILLINGNESS TO SERVE. THANK YOU
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. YEAH,
YOU ARE VOLUNTEERS, AND YOU GIV
OF YOUR TIME AND EXPERTISE. AND
SO, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL
RIGHT. WE ALSO HAVE THREE
APPOINTMENTS. THEY ARE NOT HERE
TODAY. JUST A REMINDER THAT
THOSE NAMES ARE FEMI, DR. TYRON
GRANDERSON, AND CAMILLE MALONZO
AND WE WILL NOW PROCEED TO
MOVING THESE APPOINTMENTS. I
MOVE THAT THE COMMITTEE
RECOMMENDS CONFIRMATION OF
APPOINTMENT 02470, 02471, 02472
02473, 74, 75, 76, 77, AND 78.
IS THERE A SECOND?
>> SECOND.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IT'S
BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED TO
RECOMMEND CONFIRMATION OF THE
APPOINTMENTS. AND WILL THE CLER
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON THE
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS TO
CONFIRM THE APPOINTMENTS.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR. ZERO OPPOSED
>> THE APPOINTMENTS WILL BE
FORWARDED TO THE CITY COUNCIL
SILL FOR FINAL CONSIDERATION ON
FEBRUARY 28th. YOU ARE NOT
REQUIRED TO ATTEND THE MEETING,
BUT IF YOU DO, I WILL RECOGNIZE
YOU. THANK YOU AGAIN,
CONGRATULATIONS. ALL RIGHT.
THANK YOU. AND THANK YOU, JON,
FOR BEING HERE. OKAY, WE WILL
NOW MOVE TO CONSIDER THE SIX
SURVEILLANCE IMPACT REPORTS, OR
SIRS. I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT ALL OF OUR PRESENTERS ARE
PRESENT. OKAY, I SEE BRIAN THER
AS WELL. OKAY, SO FOR SOME
BACKGROUND PER THE 2017
SURVEILLANCE ORDINANCE, CITY
DEMOCRATICS ARE REQUIRED TO
OBTAIN ADVANCED COUNCIL APPROVA
FOR THE ACQUISITION OF
TECHNOLOGY THAT MAY HAVE
SURVEILLANCE CAPACITY, SUCH AS
BINOCULARS THAT C LIGHT USES TO
READ METERS THAT COULD PUT A
WORKER AT RISK. AND DEPARTMENTS
MUST REQUEST RETROACTIVE
APPROVAL, IF THEY'RE IN USE
BEFORE THE LAW HAS BEEN IN
EFFECT, WHICH IS WHAT WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT TODAY.
SPECIFICALLY, THESE SIX BILLS
WOULD IMPROVE THE SEATTLE POLIC
DEPARTMENT'S USE OF THOSE
REPORTS, AND AN EXECUTIVE
OVERVIEW OR EACH TECHNOLOGY. ON
FEBRUARY 8th, WE HAD A JOINT
PARTICIPATION THAT WENT OVER.
THE PROCESS FOR REVIEWING
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGIES,
INCLUDING THOSE ALREADY IN USE
WHEN THE SURVEILLANCE ORDINANCE
WAS PASSED IN 2017. A
DESCRIPTION OF THE TECHNOLOGIES
IN OTHER WORDS, HOW THEY WORK.
THE RELATED LAWS AND POLICIES
THAT AUTHORIZE SPD'S USE OF
THEM, AND EXISTING LAWS AND
POLICIES THAT LIMIT SPD'S USE O
THEM. CENTRAL STAFF, LISA KAYE
IS WITH US HERE TODAY, HAD
PRESENTED A MEMORANDUM ON EACH
OF THE SIX SIR'S, THEY ARE
ATTACHED TO THE AGENDA. EACH OF
THEM PROVIDES RELEVANT
FEEDBACK, AND PROPOSES POLICY
CONSIDERATIONS THAT COULD HAVE
INFORMED AMENDMENTS TO THE
LEGISLATION. ALL RIGHT. AND I
UNDERSTAND THAT YOU HAD OFFERED
LISA, BRIEFINGS TO ALL COUNCIL,
TO ALL COMMITTEE MEMBERS BEFORE
THAT MEETING IN CASE THEY HAD
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, AND I
BELIEVE THAT YOU WILL ALSO OFFE
THAT AS WELL GOING INTO THE FUL
COUNCIL VOTE IF PEOPLE WHO
AREN'T MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTE
HAVE QUESTIONS.
>> CERTAINLY.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND SO
TODAY WE WILL DISCUSS AND
POSSIBLY VOTE ON 15 AMENDMENTS
PROPOSED BY COUNCILMEMBERS AS
WELL AS POSSIBLY VOTE THE BILLS
OUT OF COMMITTEE. AND I
MENTIONED THIS WHEN WE WERE
GOING THROUGH THE GROUP FOR A
TECHNOLOGIES LAST MAY. BUT I
JUST WANTED TO REMIND FOLKS THA
I BRING A PERSPECTIVE TO THIS
PROCESS, WHICH IS AN
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT, THAT AS A
COUNCILMEMBER AND FULFILLMENT O
MY DUTY TO PROTECT THE HEALTH O
MY CONSTITUENTS AND PURSUE
ESSENTIAL CITY LIBERTIES. AND I
ALSO MUST DO SO WITHIN THE
REALITIES OF TODAY, WHICH
INCLUDE RISING RATES OF GUN
VIOLENCE, AND OTHER CRIME FATAL
FENTANYL OVERDOSES AS WELL AS
SPD'S SEVERE STAFFING SHORTAGE.
AND TOP OF ALL OF THAT, THE
QUICK PACE OF TECHNOLOGICAL
CHANGE AND INNOVATION. SO WITH
THAT, AS A TABLE SETTING, HERE'
HOW THIS WILL WORK. AS WE GO
THROUGH THE S.I.R.'S, I WILL
FIRST MOVE THE BILL, THEN TURN
IT OVER TO LISA KAYE FROM
CENTRAL STAFF AND I DO MIKE THA
DISTINCTION, BECAUSE WE'VE GOT
ANOTHER PERSON WITH A SIMILAR
SOUNDING NAME HERE, TO INTRODUC
THE AMENDMENT BEFORE THE SPONSO
SPEAKS TO IT, AND THEN BRIAN
MASSY FROM SPD, AND SARA
CARRIER, AND SEATTLE LIGHT ARE
HERE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS AS
NEEDED. SO LET'S GET STARTED.
WILL THE CLERK PLEASE READ
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 10 INTO THE
RECORD?
>> COUNCIL BILL 120499. AN
ORDINANCE RELATING TO
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
IMPLEMENTATION, AUTHORIZING THE
APPROVAL OF USES AND ACCEPTING
THE 2022 SURVEILLANCE IMPACT AN
2022 EXECUTIVE ORDER VIEW FOR
THE SEATTLE POLICE DEPARTMENT'S
USE OF CAMERA SYSTEMS, IMAGES O
NONAUDITORY VIDEO RECORDINGS.
>> I MOVE TO PASS IT. IT'S BEEN
MOVED AND SECONDED TO RECOMMEND
PASSAGE OF THE BILL.
>> IF YOU WILL BEAR WITH ME, I
WILL SHARE MY SCREEN HERE, SO
THAT YOU WILL SEE THE AMENDMENT
AS I SPEAK TO THEM. IT LOOKS
LIKE THAT'S WORKING FOR YOU
THEN.
>> YES.
>> OH, GOOD. OKAY. SO I WOULD -
I'M LISA KAYE, COUNCIL STAFF,
AS YOU MENTIONED. AS I BEGIN TO
WALK THROUGH THESE AMENDMENTS,
FOR EACH OF THE SIX BILLS, YOU
WILL SEE AMENDMENTS ONE AND TWO
ARE IDENTICAL. BOTH OF THESE AR
SPONSORED BY COUNCILMEMBER
HERBOLD, SO I WILL EXPLAIN THEM
ONE TIME, BASICALLY, AND THEN
TURN THEM OVER ONE AT A TIME FO
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD TO SPEAK
TO, AS WE GO THROUGH AMENDMENTS
OR THE SUBSEQUENT BILLS. I MAY
NOT BE REPEATING MYSELF FOR
THESE TWO. SO WE'LL START WITH
AMENDMENT ONE TO COUNCIL BILL
120499. THIS WOULD ASK THE
POLICE DEPARTMENT TO WORK WITH
THE OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
TO DEVELOP EQUITY AMENDMENTS FO
THE ANNUAL EQUITY ASSESSMENTS O
THESE CAMERA SYSTEMS. IT ALSO
ASKS THE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND
OIG TO WORK TOGETHER TO SUPPORT
OI G'S DISPROPORTIONAL IMPACTS
OF THE TECHNOLOGY AS ANNUAL
REVIEW OF THE CAMERA SYSTEMS.
WITH THAT, I WILL TURN IT OVER
TO SPONSOR COUNCILMEMBER
HERBOLD.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD, YOU
ARE RECOGNIZED TO MOVE THE FIRS
AMENDMENT.
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH. I MOVE
AMENDMENT ONE. AM I MOVING IT
JUST TO THE SINGLE BILL? WE'RE
GOING THROUGH EACH ONE
INDIVIDUALLY? THAT HAS TO BE TH
PROCESS. YES.
>> THANK YOU. I MOVE AMENDMENT
TO COUNCIL BILL 120499.
>> SECOND.
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
>> MOVED AND SECONDED TO ADOPT
AMENDMENT 1 IS PRESENTED ON THE
AGENDA. COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD
HAS SPONSORED. YOU'RE RECOGNIZE
TO ADDRESS IT.
>> FOR EACH OF THE TECHNOLOGY
BILLS I INTRODUCE A METRIC'S
ASSESSMENT. I APPRECIATE THAT
THE BACKLOG IS SURVEILLANCE
TECHNOLOGIES HAVE -- THE
S.I.R.'S HAVE BEEN APPROVED WIT
THE INCLUSION OF THESE EQUITY
METRICS AMENDMENTS IN THE
APPROXIMATE PAST. THESE AMENDS
REQUEST SPD TO COLLABORATE TO
BOTH ONE NAME THE METRICS THAT
WILL BE USED IN THE REQUIRED
ASSESSMENTS CONCERNING THE USE
OF THESE TECHNOLOGIES, AND THEY
ALSO REQUEST SPD TO WORK WITH
OIG TO DEVELOP THE AUDIT LOG TO
SUPPORT THE OIG'S ANNUAL
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY USAGE
REVIEW. THE AMENDMENT ITSELF
DOES NOT PRESUPPOSE THE DATA TO
BE CAPTURED IN THE AUDIT LOG. S
I JUST HOPE NO ONE IS CONCERNED
ABOUT THE CONTENT OF THE AWE
DIETED LOG, BECAUSE I'M REALLY
CONFIDENT IS THAT SPD AND OIG
WILL NOT COULD CREATE AN AUDIT
LOG THAT SPD DOES NOT SUPPORT.
THEY'RE EQUAL PARTNERS CREATING
THE AUDIT LOG, AND IT'S NOT LIK
IT'S COMING BACK TO US FOR
APPROVAL OR DISAPPROVAL, IT'S
JUST HOME WORK THAT THE COUNCIL
IS ASKING THEM TO COLLABORATE T
DOING TO THE. THE SURVEILLANCE
ORDINANCE EXISTS TO PROTECT
CIVIL LIBERTIES AND PREVENT USE
OF SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY WHIL
ALSO SUPPORTING THE BASIC
UNDERPINNINGS OF THE
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGIES USE I
FULFILLING THE POLICE
DEPARTMENT'S EFFORTS TO -- IN
PUBLIC SAFETY, AND THIS
AMENDMENT IS A CRITICAL FOR OUR
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY LOG.
FURTHER CONCERNS ABOUT
COLLECTING DATA THAT WILL BE
SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE OR
SPD'S ABILITY TO USE THESE
TECHNOLOGIES, AGAIN, I DON'T
BELIEVE THAT THE OFFICE OF THE
INSPECTOR GENERAL WILL CO-CREAT
WITH SPD AN AUDIT LOG THAT WOUL
HAVE THOSE VULNERABILITIES, AND
OUR PUBLIC DISCLOSURE LAWS AND
NSPD'S POLICIES ALLOW THE
DEPARTMENT TO REDACT SENSITIVE
INFORMATION, PROTECTION OF
PEOPLE'S RIGHTS TO PRIVACY, AND
SO THIS MEANS THAT IN COMPLETIN
A PUBLIC DISCLOSURE REQUEST, SP
COULD REDACT INFORMATION THAT
WOULD COMPROMISE AN ACTIVE OPEN
INVESTIGATION. SO AGAIN, AS WE
EXPECT THE OIG AND SPD TO
COLLABORATE TO NAME THE KINDS O
METRICS THEY NEED TO TRACK AND
AUDIT, WE EXPECT THEM TO COLLEC
AND RETAIN THE INFORMATION ONLY
RELEVANT TO THE GOALS OF USING
APPROPRIATE USE OF THE
TECHNOLOGIES. SO IN ESSENCE, IF
THERE IS A PROBLEM WITH
DISPROPORTIONATE USE OF
TECHNOLOGIES, WE CAN'T CORRECT
IT IF WE DON'T FIND IT, SO THIS
DATA COLLECT IS HOW WE DISCOVER
PREVENT, AND CORRECT AN ISSUE
WITH A DEPLOYMENT OF THIS
TECHNOLOGY IF ONE IN FACT DOES
EXIST. THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I
SUPPORT THE REQUEST TO DEVELOP
THE EQUITY METRICS, AND WE
INCLUDED THIS AMENDMENT IN THE
SARS FOR GROUP 4A LAST MAY. I
DID, AS I WAS GOING THROUGH
THESE, HAVE QUESTIONS THAT I
MENTIONED TO YOU YESTERDAY ABOU
THE DISCLOSABLE NATURE OF THIS
INFORMATION AND HOW AN AUDIT LO
COULD, OR COULD NOT INTERFERE,
AND WORSE HELP PEOPLE FIGURE OU
HOW TO COMMIT CRIMES WITH
IMPUNITY IF THEY HAVE A BETTER
UNDERSTAND OF THIS TECHNOLOGY,
HOW IT'S DEPLOYED, ET CETERA, E
CETERA, AND I ENDED UP LAST
NIGHT HAVING A CONVERSATION WIT
INSPECTOR GENERAL LISA JUDGE AS
WELL AS BRIAN MAXEY, WHO IS HER
WITH US TODAY. AND SO, I
UNDERSTAND THAT THEY ARE BOTH I
SUPPORT, OR HAVE NO CONCERNS
ABOUT THIS. BUT I WOULD LIKE,
YOU BRIAN, TO EXPAND ON YOUR
COMMENTS. SO GO AHEAD, PLEASE.
>> THANK YOU, COUNCILMEMBER.
YEAH, SPD HAS NO OBJECTION TO
THESE AMENDMENTS. THESE ARE
CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE'VE DONE
IN PRIOR SIR'S, AND WE ARE FULL
OPTIMISTIC OF THE ABILITY TO
WORK WITH THE INSPECTOR GENERAL
TO DEVELOP THE METRICS AND LOG
AND FULLY SUPPORT THIS.
>> EXCELLENT.
>> PARDON ME? SO COLLEAGUES, DO
YOU HAVE, DOES ANYONE ELSE --
>> WHAT'S THAT YOU SAID?
>>
>> HEY, ERIC.
>> IS THERE A MALFUNCTION,
STEVEN? I DON'T KNOW WHO WAS
LAST SPEAKING. ERIC OR
COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS. SEEINGNO
QUESTIONS, I BELIEVE WE ARE
PREPARED TO PROCEED. IF MY
QUESTIONS HAVE NO -- IF MY
COLLEAGUES HAVE NO FURTHER
COMMENTS, WILL THE CLERK PLEASE
CALL THE ROLE ON ADOPTION OF
AMENDMENT 1.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE VOTES IN FAVOR, ZERO
OPPOSED.
>> OKAY THE MOTION CARRIES.
AMENDMENT ONE IS ADOPTED, AND
THE AMENDED BILL IS BEFORE THE
COUNCIL. LISA, WOULD YOU PLEASE
WALK THROUGH AMENDMENT TWO.
>> THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. AMEN
TWO IS ALSO SPONSORED BY
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD. THIS
WOULD ASK IS THE POLICE
DEPARTMENT TO DEVELOP A POLICY
NO LATER THAN THE END OF THIS
YEAR, SPECIFIC TO A YOUTH'S
CONSENT FOR USE OF THESE CAMERA
SYSTEMS. THESE POLICIES WOULD
REFLECT THE PROVISIONS WHICH
WOULD REQUIRE COUNCIL BE
AVAILABLE IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS
WE WILL TURN IT OVER TO
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH. AS
MENTIONED, AMENDMENT 2 IS AN
AMENDMENT WE WILL SEE FOR ALL O
THESE INDIVIDUAL S.I.R.'S, FOR
THESE DIFFERENT TECHNOLOGIES.
THE CONCEPT OF DISCUSSED IN
COMMITTEE LAST TIME WE MET. IT
SIMPLY IS DESIGNED TO ENSURE
THAT THE TECHNOLOGIES THAT
REQUIRE THE USE OF A WARRANT OR
CONSENT OF AN INDIVIDUAL IS, IS
IMPLEMENTED IN A WAY THAT IS
CONSISTENT WITH COUNCIL BILL
1140. THE YOUTH RIGHTS
ORDINANCE, AND JUST MAKE SURE
THAT THE DEPARTMENT HAS POLICIE
IN PLACE TO ENSURE THAT LEGAL
COUNSEL FOR ANY YOUTH THAT WOUL
BE QUESTIONED OR SEARCHED IN
THESE, IN THESE PARTICULAR, IN
THE USE OF THESE PARTICULAR
TECHNOLOGIES HAVE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE LEGAL
COUNSEL MADE AVAILABLE TO THEM.
>> THANK YOU. WOULD YOU PLEASE
MOVE THE AMENDMENT?
>> THANK YOU, I MOVE AMENDMENT
TWO TO COUNCIL BILL 120249.
>> SECOND.
>> MUCH APPRECIATED.
>> ALL RIGHT, SO I HAD A
QUESTION ABOUT, ABOUT THE
AMENDMENT. AS THE TEXT NOTES,
SPD ALREADY IS SUBJECT TO CITY
AND STATE LAW THAT REQUIRES THE
TO PROVIDE [ INAUDIBLE ] WHO
RECEIVE A MIRANDA WARNING OR AR
ASKED TO GIVE CONSENT TO A
SEARCH. AS WE HEARD IN
DISCUSSION ON FEBRUARY 8th, THE
ALREADY HAD THE POLICY. THEY
ALREADY HAVE POLICY TO THAT
EFFECT. CAN YOU EXPLAIN HOW THI
EXPANDS OR CHANGES WHAT IS
ALREADY IN EFFECT?
>> SURE, SO THE POLICIES, AS I
UNDERSTAND THEM, THAT ARE
COMPLIANT WITH THE LEGISLATION
OF THE COUNCIL PASSED AND
SUBSEQUENT TO THE COUNCIL
PASSING THIS LEGISLATION, STATE
LAW WAS ALSO CHALLENGED TO
INFLECT SIMILAR INTENT. BUT AS
UNDERSTAND IT, THOSE POLICIES
ARE FOCUSED ON PERSON TO PERSON
SEARCHES AND CONSENTS. AND SO
THIS IS REALLY ABOUT THE USE OF
THE TECHNOLOGY AND MAKING SURE
THAT THE POLICIES THAT SPD HAS
CREATED ALSO INCORPORATES THE
USE OF THE TECHNOLOGIES.
>> OKAY, THANK YOU FOR THAT..
ARE THERE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS O
COMMENTS FROM MY COLLEAGUES OR
FROM THE PRESENTERS? OKAY,
SEEING NONE, WILL THE CLERK
PLEASE CALL THE ROLE ON THE
ADOPTION OF COUNCIL BILL TWO.
AMENDMENT TWO IS ADOPTED. IF
THERE ARE NO FURTHER COMMENTS,
I'M NOT SEEING ANY, WILL THE
CLERK PLEASE CALL THE ROLE ON
THE COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION
THAT THE BILL PASS AS
AMENDMENTED.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THE RECOMMENDATION THAT THE
BILL PASS WILL BE FORWARDED TO
THE CITY COUNCIL SILL FOR
CONSIDERATION ON FEBRUARY 28th
AND BECAUSE THESE TWO AMENDMENT
ARE ATTACHED TO EACH TECHNOLOGY
I WILL NOT HAVE COMMENTS ON THE
AT EACH TIME, EXCEPT THERE ARE
COUPLE POINTS WHEN THE YOUTH
COUNCIL DOES -- I HAVE QUESTION
ABOUT THE SPECIFIC TECHNOLOGY.
BUT IN GENERAL JUST LETTING
FOLKS KNOW THAT MY QUESTIONS
WERE ADDRESSED IN AMENDMENT ONE
AND I DON'T NEED TO SPEAK TO
THOSE FURTHER GOING FORWARD. AL
RIGHT. WILL THE CLERK PLEASE
CALL ITEM 11 INTO THE RECORD?
>> WITH AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 11.
COUNCIL BILL 120500. AN
ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING APPROVE
ALLEGE OF USES, AND ACCEPTING
THE 2022 SURVEILLANCE IMPACT
REPORT AND 2022 EXECUTIVE
OVERVIEW FOR THE SEATTLE POLICE
DEPARTMENT'S DATA.
>> I RECOMMEND APPROVAL. IS
THERE A SECOND?
>> SECOND.
>> IT'S BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED
AND RECOMMEND PASSAGE OF THE
BILL. LISA, HOW WOULD YOU LIKE
TO PROCEED GOING FORWARD? I WIL
ASK YOU EACH TIME IF IT YOU
WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT.
>> IF IT WORKS WITH YOU,
COUNCILMEMBER, YOU COULD JUST
SKIP ME COMPLETELY, AND JUST AS
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD IF SHE
WISHES TO MOVE EACH AMENDMENT,
AND ADD ANY COMMENTS.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL
RIGHT. DO YOU CARE TO MOVE THE
AMENDMENT? THANK YOU.
>> I WILL INDEED. I MOVE
AMENDMENT ONE TO, LET'S SEE,
WE'RE OWN COUNCIL BILL 120500.
>> YES. SECOND. IT'S BEEN MOVED
AND SECONDED TO RECOMMEND
PASSAGE. SORRY ABOUT THAT. IT'S
BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED TO ADOP
AMENDMENT ONE AS PRESENTED ON
THE AGENDA. AND DO YOU HAVE
SPECIFIC COMMENTS ON THIS? OKAY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY OTHER
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS? SEEING
NONE, WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CAL
THE ROLE ON THE ADOPTION OF
AMENDMENT ONE?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THE
MOTION CARRIES. AMENDMENT ONE I
ADOPTED, AND THE AMENDED BILL I
BEFORE COUNCIL. WOULD YOU PLEAS
MOVE AMENDMENT TWO?
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT TWO TO
COUNCIL BILL 120500.
>> SECOND. ALL RIGHT. IT'S BEE
MOVED AND SECONDED TO ADOPT
AMENDMENT TWO AS PRESENTED ON
THE AGENDA. I DID HAVE A
QUESTION ABOUT THIS. THIS IS
REGARDING CRASH DATA RETRIEVAL
TOOLS. BECAUSE THEY PULL DATA
DIRECTLY FROM THE SYSTEMS ON TH
VEHICLE, CAN YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN
BRIAN, HOW THIS POLICY WILL PLA
OUT IN REAL LIFE WITH -- IF
YOUTH ARE INVOLVED?
>> THANK YOU COUNCILMEMBER. SO
MY UNDERSTANDING IS THIS IS
REALLY APPLYING THE ORDINANCE T
YOUTH'S CONSENT IN THIS
PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCE. MY
GUESS IS THAT WOULD WHEN A
JUVENILE IS DRIVING A VEHICLE
AND WE WANT TO GET THE CRASH
DATA OUT OF THAT VEHICLE. I
THINK OUR CURRENT SYSTEM WOULD
NOT LET US GET THE INFORMATION
OUT OF THE VEHICLE. AND WE WOUL
GO TO A PARENT OR COUNSEL. THIS
STATES IF WE WERE TO ASK A
JUVENILE FOR CONSEND TO PULL TH
CRASH DATA INFORMATION, THEY
WOULD NEED TO HAVE COUNCIL HELP
THEM WITH A DECISION. I DON'T
THINK THIS WOULD ACTUALLY CHANG
OUR CURRENT PRACTICE IN ANY WAY
BUT IT A GREAT BACK STOP TO
ENSURE THAT JUVENILES ARE NOT
GIVING CONSENT WITHOUT LEGAL
COUNCIL.
>> THAT ANSWERS MY QUESTION.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WILL THE
CLERK PLEASE CALL THE ROLE ON
ADOPTION OF AMENDMENT 2?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD?
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER NELL NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD?
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON?
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR. THE
RECOMMENDATION THAT THE BILL
PASS WILL BE FORWARDED TO FULL
COUNCIL ON FEBRUARY 28th. LET'S
MOVE ONTO AGENDA ITEM 12,
PLEASE.
>> COUNCIL BILL 120501. AN
ORDINANCE RATING TO SURVEILLANC
TECHNOLOGY ORIENTATION,
ACCEPTING THE 2022 SURVEILLANCE
IMPACT REPORT, AND 2022
EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW FOR THE
SEATTLE POLICE DEPARTMENT'S USE
OF COMPUTER, CELL PHONE AND
MOBILE DEVICE EXTRACTION TOOLS.
>> THANK YOU, I MOVE THAT THE
COMMITTEE RECOMMEND PASSAGE OF
120501. IS THERE A SECOND?
>> SECOND.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IT'S
BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED TO
RECOMMEND PASSAGE OF THE BILL.
AGAIN, THERE ARE TWO AMENDMENTS
TO THIS BILL. AND WOULD YOU
PLEASE MOVE AMENDMENT ONE?
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT ONE TO
COUNCIL BILL 120501.
>> SECOND. IT'S BEEN MOVED AND
SECONDED TO ADOPT AMENDMENT ONE
ON THE AGENDA. IF THERE ARE NO
COMMENTS I WILL PROCEED TO A
VOTE. SEEING NONE. GO AHEAD,
PLEASE, WITH THE ROLL CALL.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THANK YOU, THE MOTION
CARRIES, AMENDMENT ONE IS
ADOPTED. YOU ARE FREE TO MOVE
AMENDMENT TWO.
>> THANK YOU, I MOVE AMENDMENT
TWO, TO COUNCIL BILL 120501.
>> SECOND. OKAY. WILL THE CLERK
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON THE
ADOPTION OF AMENDMENT TWO?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> AMENDMENT TWO IS ADOPTED.
AND LAST CALL, ANY LAST
QUESTIONS ON THIS BILL BEFORE W
PROCEED TO A VOTE? SEEING NONE,
WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ON THE RECOMMENDATION THAT
THE BILL PASS AS AMENDMENTED?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD?
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> ITEM 13, PLEASE.
>> AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 13.
COUNCIL BILL 120502.
AUTHORIZING APPROVAL OF USES AN
ACCEPTING THE 2022 SURVEILLANCE
IMPACT REPORT AND 2022 EXECUTIV
OVERVIEW FOR THE SEATTLE POLICE
DEPARTMENT'S USE OF GEOTIME.
>> I MOVE THAT THE COMMITTEE
RECOMMEND PASSAGE OF 120502. IS
THERE A SECOND?
>> SECOND.
>> THANK YOU. IT'S BEEN MOVED
AND SECONDED TO RECOMMEND
PASSAGE OF THE BILL. WOULD YOU
PLEASE MOVE AMENDMENT ONE.
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT ONE TO
COUNCIL BILL 120502.
>> SECOND. OKAY. IT'S BEEN
MOVED AND SECONDED TO ADOPT
AMENDMENT ONE. WOULD THE CLERK
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THE MOTION CARRIES AND
AMENDMENT ONE IS ADOPTED, YOU
ARE FREE TO MOVE AMENDMENT TWO.
>> THANK YOU. I'D LIVE TO MOVE
AMENDMENT TWO TO COUNSEL BILL
120502.
>> COUNCIL BILL 120502.
>> SECONDED. OKAY IT'S BEEN
MOVED AND SECONDED. I DO HAVE
QUESTION ABOUT THIS ONE, BECAUS
IT'S A DIFFERENT TECHNOLOGY.
GEOTIME IS A TOOL THAT ANALYZES
DATA THAT SPD HAS ALREADY
GATHERED. CAN YOU PLEASE, IF
THERE ARE NO YOUTH JUVENILES
PRESENT AT THE MOMENT, CAN YOU
PLEASE JUST WALK US THROUGH,
BRIAN, AGAIN HOW THIS WILL BE
APPLIED?
>>
>> I'M SORRY, COUNCILMEMBER,
WAS THAT TO ME?
>> YES, IT IS.
>> I ACTUALLY DO NOT KNOW HOW
GEOTIME WOULD BE USED TO
QUESTION A JUVENILE. IT'S SIMPL
A BACK END OF OUR EXISTING DATA
THAT BEING SAID, THERE'S NO
REASON WE COULD NOT DRAFT A
POLICY CONSISTENT WITH THE
LIMITATIONS IN THE ORDINANCE.
I'M UNSURE HOW IT WOULD ACTUALL
APPLY, BUT I DO NOT SEE HOW THI
WOULD IMPAIR OUR EFFORTS IN ANY
WAY.
>> GO AHEAD, COUNCILMEMBER
HERBOLD.
>> I'LL GIVE IT A SHOT HERE,
LISA. IF THERE'S FILLING IN
HERE, I WOULD CERTAINLY
APPRECIATE IT. BUT I THINK
THERE'S AN OUTSTANDING QUESTION
ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT DATA CAN B
MANUALLY INPUT INTO GEOTIME, AN
WHETHER OR NOT DATA THAT IS
MANUALLY INPUT INTO GEOTIME CAN
ACTUALLY BE OBTAINED WITHOUT A
WARRANT, AND BASED ON TWO PARTY
CONSENT ALONE. SO THIS IS,
AGAIN, AS COO MAXEY DESCRIBED,
BACK STOP TO ADDRESS THE
INSTANCE IN IN WHICH THE DATA
PUT INTO GEOTIME IN CASES WHERE
IT IS NECESSARY TO USE A WARRAN
OR TWO PARTY CONSENT TO OBTAIN
THAT INFORMATION, IT'S FOR THOS
PARTICULAR INSTANCES.
>> LISA, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING T
ADD?
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD NAILED
IT.
>> WOW. I THOUGHT THAT WAS LIKE
CLEAR AS MUD. SO THANK YOU.
>> OKAY. SO I'M ASSUMING THAT
EVERYONE IS ONBOARD WITH THIS,
AND I WILL JUST ASK THAT IF
THERE ARE DIFFICULTIES AFTER TH
COMMITTEE WITH THE APPLICATION
OF THIS, PLEASE LET US KNOW, BU
I'M PLANNING ON SUPPORTING THIS
TODAY. ANY OTHER COMMENTS? OKAY
WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE
ROLE ON THE ADOPTION OF
AMENDMENT NUMBER TWO.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THE MOTION CARRIES, AMENDMEN
TWO IS ADOPTED, AND THE AMENDED
BILL IS NOW BEFORE COUNCIL.
WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLE
ON THE COMMITTEE VOTE THAT THE
BILL PASS AS LISTED?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD?
>> YES. CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> WE WILL CONSIDER THIS ON
FEBRUARY 28th. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. LET'S PROCEED NOW TO
AGENDA ITEM 14.
>> AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 14.
COUNCIL BILL 120503. AN
ORDINANCE RELATING TO
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
IMPLEMENTATION, AUTHORIZING
APPROVAL OF USES, AND ACCEPTING
THE 2022 SURVEILLANCE IMPACT
REPORT AND 2022 EXECUTIVE
OVERVIEW FOR THE SEATTLE POLICE
DEPARTMENT'S USE OF REMOTELY
OPERATED VEHICLES.
>> IS THERE A SECOND?
>> SECOND.
>> IT'S BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED
TO RECOMMEND PASSAGE OF THE
BILL, AND THERE ARE FIVE
AMENDMENTS TO THIS. AND LISA,
PLEASE PRESENT THE FIRST
AMENDMENT. WELL, I WILL HOLD ON
THAT. WE CAN SKIP THE FIRST AND
SECOND PRESENTATIONS, AND JUST
GO STRAIGHT INTO THE VOTES ON
THOSE, AND THEN WE WILL HAVE YO
PRESENT ON THE THIRD. ALL RIGHT
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD, YOUR FRE
TO MOVE.
>> I VOTE TO MOVE COUNCIL BILL
10120503.
>> IT'S BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED
WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS?
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD? CHAIR
NELSON? THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THANK YOU, THE MOTION
CARRIES, AMENDMENT ONE IS
ADOPTED. LET'S MOVE ONTO TWO.
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT TWO TO
COUNCIL BILL 120503.
>> SECOND. OKAY, IT'S BEEN MOVE
AROUND SECONDED. SEEING NO
QUESTIONS, WILL THE CLERK PLEAS
CALL THE ROLL?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS?
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD?
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> OKAY . NOW WE'RE ABOUT TO
MOVE. SO I'M NOT GOING TO ASK
THAT QUESTION. ALL RIGHT. LET'S
CALL THE ROLL ON THE BILL.
>> I THINK THIS ONE HAS THREE.
>> EXCUSE ME. I'M SORRY ABOUT
THAT. LISA COULD YOU PLEASE
INTRODUCE AMENDMENT THREE AND
THEN WE WILL MOVE IT FORMALLY.
>> YES, COUNCILMEMBER. AMENDMEN
THREE IS SPONSORED BY
COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD. IT WILL
ASK THE POLICE DEPARTMENT TO
DEVELOP A POLICY BY THE END OF
THIS YEAR REQUIRING THAT DATA
COLLECTED BY A REMOTELY OPERATE
VEHICLE THAT'S NOT NEEDED FOR A
INVESTIGATION BE DELETED
IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE 90 DA
RETENSION PERIOD, WHICH IS SET
BY THE STATE RECORD'S RETENSION
SCHEDULE.
>> THANK YOU. GO AHEAD.
>> THANK YOU SO MUCH. SO AN
EARLIER DRAFT OF THE AMENDMENT
REQUESTED A POLICY REQUIRING TH
IMMEDIATE DELETION OF DATA, BUT
WE FOUND OUT AFTER CONSULTING
WITH THE CLERK'S OFFICE, THERE'
A 90 DAY MANDATORY RETENSION
PERIOD, SO THIS REQUIRES THE
DELETION OF ANY DATA COLLECTED
BY ROV'S AFTER THAT MANDATORY
RETENSION PERIOD, OF COURSE
PURSUANT TO ALL STATE LAWS AND
CITY LAWS, AND AS APPROVED BY
THE CITY LAW DEPARTMENT. THE
EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW CONFIRMS THA
THE IMAGES AND DATA ARE NOT
CURRENTLY STORED OR RETAINED.
THIS JUST MAKES SURE THAT IF
THOSE POLICIES WERE TO CHANGE,
THAT SPD MAINTAINS THESE CURREN
PROCEDURES.
>> GOT IT. SO HOW IS INFORMATIO
DEEMED NOT TO BE NECESSARY OR
OF VALUE FOR AN INVESTIGATION?
>> I THINK THAT'S A QUESTION
THAT WE WILL NOT BE IN THE
DRIVER'S SEAT, THANKFULLY OF
DETERMINING. BUT SPD WILL BE.
>> THAT IS ONE OF THE QUESTIONS
THAT I HAVE, IS IF THIS IS
DELETED AFTER 90 DAYS, A WHAT
POINT IS THERE AN ISSUE THAT
THAT INFORMATION COULD BE NEEDE
AT A LATER POINT OF THE
INVESTIGATION OR IN TRIALS GOIN
FORWARD, EITHER BY THE
PROSECUTION, OR THE DEFENDANT?
AM ASKING YOU, BRIAN, IF THERE
ARE ANY QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS
ABOUT THIS POLICY?
>> THANK YOU, COUNCILMEMBER.
THIS IS A POLICY CHOICE. I
TYPICALLY -- WE RETAIN
INFORMATION FOR LONGER THAN A 9
DAY PERIOD, IN CASE THERE WAS A
OPA COMPLAINT OR A LAWSUIT THAT
WAS FILED. BUT IN TERMS OF
DETERMINING WHAT IS NECESSARY
FOR AN INVESTIGATION, THAT'S
PART AND PARCEL OF WHAT WE DO
HERE. I WOULD ASSUME THAT WOULD
INCLUDE AN ADMINISTRATIVE
INVESTIGATION IF THIS WERE PART
OF A CURRENT OPA INVESTIGATION,
OR INVESTIGATION INTO ANY USE O
FORCE. NOT THAT WE ANTICIPATE
THAT WITH OUR REMOTELY OPERATED
VEHICLES, BUT CERTAINLY OUR
SYSTEMS COULD INCLUDE SOMETHING
IF WE NEED TO FURTHER OUR
INVESTIGATION. BUT ALL OF THAT
WOULD FALL UNDER THE
INVESTIGATION HEADER. I GUESS M
ONLY QUESTION WOULD BE WITH
SUBSEQUENT LAWS FOR SOMETHING W
DEEMED NOT NECESSARY FOR AN
INVESTIGATION AND PURGED WHAT
THE CITY RESPONSE WOULD BE TO
THE INABILITY TO PROVIDE THAT.
BUT OPERATIONALLY, I DO NOT SEE
THIS AS A BURDEN IN ANY WAY.
>> THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR CONCERNS
> OKAY. I'M GOING TO DECLINE MY
SUPPORT ON THIS ONE, BECAUSE OF
THE POTENTIAL THAT THAT
INFORMATION IS NEEDED IN THE
FUTURE FOR FUTURE LAWSUITS. AND
THANK YOU FOR UNDERSTANDING THA
POSITION. OKAY, WILL THE CLERK
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON ADOPTIO
OF AMENDMENT 3.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON. NAY.
>> TWO IN FAVOR, ONE OPPOSED.
>> THE MOTION CARRIES, AMENDMEN
THREE IS ADOPTED. LISA, COULD
YOU PLEASE PRESENT AMENDMENT
FOUR.
>> AMENDMENT FOUR IS SPONSORED
BY COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD. THIS
WILL ASK THE POLICE DEPARTMENT
TO DEVELOP A POSITIVE BY THE
YEAR, PROHIBITING CELL PHONES
FROM THE DISPLAY ON A REMOTELY
OPERATED VEHICLE.
>> OKAY. COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT FOUR.
>> YES. SECOND.
>> THANK YOU. AND IF I COULD
JUST HAVE A COUPLE WORDS. SO AS
LISA EXPLAINED, THE AMENDMENT
WOULD REQUIRE SPD TO DEVELOP
POLICIES PROHIBITING THE USE OF
CELL PHONES TO RECORD THE LIVE
STREAM ON THE REMOTELY OPERATED
VEHICLE DISPLAY. AS EXPLAINED
EARLIER FOR THE PREVIOUS
AMENDMENT, THE ROV USED BY SWAT
IN THE ARSON BOMB UNITS DO NOT
STORE OR RETAIN IMAGES OR DATA.
SO THIS AMENDMENT CLOSES A
POTENTIAL ROUNDABOUT WAY TO
RECORD THE IMAGES CAPTURED BY
THE RO V'S AND WAS RECOMMENDED
BY THE WORKING GROUP.
>> THIS SEEMS LIKE A NO-BRAINER
TO ME. WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL TH
ROLL?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS?
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THE
MOTION CARRIES. AMENDMENT FOUR
IS ADOPTED. LET'S MOVE ONTO
AMENDMENT FIVE.
>> THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. THIS
IS THE LAST OF THE FIVE
AMENDMENTS FOR THIS BILL. THIS
IS SPONSORED BY COUNCILMEMBER
HERBOLD. IT ASKS THE POLICE
DEPARTMENT TO DEVELOP A POLICY
BY THE END OF THIS YEAR
PROHIBITING THE USE OF REMOTELY
OPERATED VEHICLES THAT ARE
DESCRIBED IN THIS SIR TO DEPLOY
WEAPONS.
>> YOU'RE FREE TO MOVE THE BILL
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT FIVE TO
COUNCIL BILL 120503.
>> SECOND.
>> SURE. I WILL ADDRESS THE
AMENDMENT FURTHER. THANK YOU
LISA KAYE FOR YOUR ASSISTANCE
TODAY AS WELL AS IN DEVELOPING
THESE AMENDMENTS. AS LISA
DESCRIBED, IT PROHIBITS THE USE
OF THESE REMOTELY OPERATED
VEHICLES FROM DEPLOYING WEAPONS
AS THE TECHNOLOGIES ARE BEING
PRESENTED TODAY. THE DESIGN IS
SPECIFICALLY FOR DEVELOPING ONL
SITUATIONAL AWARENESS, AND
COMPLETING SOME SIMPLE MANUAL
TASKS. IT'S IMPORTANT THAT AS W
APPROVE THE SURVEILLANCE
TECHNOLOGIES WE'RE DOING WHAT W
CAN TO ENSURE THAT THEY REMAIN
IN USE FOR THE PURPOSE THAT WE
ARE AUTHORIZING THEIR USE. AND
SO, ANY FUTURE TECHNOLOGIES
ACQUIRED BY SPD TO SURVEIL AND
REMOTELY DEPLOY WEAPONS WITH
THIS LIMITATION THAT WE'RE
PUTTING ON IT RIGHT NOW WOULD
REQUIRE THE TECHNOLOGY TO COME
BACK FOR A REVIEW.
>> THE S.I.R. IN THIS ENTIRE
PROCESS IS ABOUT SURVEILLANCE,
BUT THIS AMENDMENT WOULD GO
BEYOND, WOULD GO BEYOND THAT US
THAT IS REVIEWED BY THE PUBLIC
AND BOTH DEPARTMENTS. SO HOW
DOES A DIFFERENT USE IN THIS
CASE, TACTICAL DECISIONS AND
EMERGENCY SITUATIONS, HOW IS
THAT -- HOW WOULD THAT BE
INCORPORATED INTO THIS PROCESS?
LISA, COULD YOU SPEAK TO THAT
PLEASE?
>> YES. TO THE EXTENT THAT THE
DEPARTMENT WOULD HAVE ANY.
>> I'M SORRY. GO ON.
>> ARE YOU SURE? OKAY. TO THE
EXTENT THAT THE DEPARTMENT WOUL
VERY ANY VEHICLES REMOTELY
OPERATED VEHICLES THAT DEPLOY
WEAPONS, THOSE THAT ARE NOT
THESE MODELS, THAT ARE APPROVED
IN THIS BILL, THAT WOULD BE A
DIFFERENT QUESTION, A DIFFERENT
POLICY ISSUE. THIS IS BASICALLY
SAYING IN ESSENCE, YOU'RE
REPEATING WHAT THIS ALREADY
SAYS. THIS DOES NOT SPEAK TO
WEAPONS DEPLOYMENT AS A USE OF
THIS TECHNOLOGY. IT'S ALREADY
PROHIBITED BY THE S.I.R. SO THI
IS BASICALLY REINFORCING THAT,
AND SAYING YOU NEED A POLICY
THAT SAYS THIS SURVEILLANCE
TECHNOLOGY CANNOT BE USED TO
DEPLOY WEAPONS. IF THERE IS A
KIND OF A TECHNOLOGY, A REMOTEL
OPERATED ROBOT OR SOMETHING THA
CAN DEPLOY WEAPONS, THAT'S A
WHOLE DIFFERENT QUESTION. AND
YOU COULDN'T AMENDMENT THIS
LEGISLATION TO AMEND THAT
DEPLOYMENT.
>> THANK YOU. AND CAPTAIN BRIT
DID SAY LAST TIME THIS IS
ALREADY NOT A PRACTICE. BUT I'M
SORRY THAT COUNCILMEMBER
HERBOLD, EARLIER, YOU BEGAN
SPEAKING.
>> IT'S OKAY.
>> MR. MAXEY, DO YOU HAVE ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ABOUT
THIS?
>> JUST A SINGLE COMMENT. THANK
YOU, COUNCILMEMBER. THE SEATTLE
POLICE DEPARTMENT HAS NO INTENT
TO WEAPONIZE ANY OF ITS REMOTEL
OPERATED VEHICLES. I JUST WANT
TO MAKE THAT CLEAR. THANK YOU.
>> OKAY. SEEING NO OTHER
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS, WOULD YO
PLEASE CALL THE ROLE ON
AMENDMENT FIVE?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THE MOTION CARRIES, AMENDMEN
FIVE IS ADOPTED. AND WE'RE NOW
GOING TO PROCEED TO THE VOTE ON
THE WHOLE BILL, UNLESS THERE AR
FURTHER COMMENTS. ALL RIGHT,
WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ON THE COMMITTEE
RECOMMENDATION THAT THE BILL
PASS AS AMENDED.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON?
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO CITY
COUNCIL FOR FINAL CONSIDERATION
AND WE ARE NOW ON AGENDA ITEM
15.
>> AGENDA ITEM 15. COUNCIL BILL
120504. AN ORDINANCE RELATING T
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
IMPLICATION, AUTHORIZING
APPROVAL OF USES, AND ACCEPTING
THE 2022 SURVEILLANCE IMPACT
REPORT AND THE 2022 BECKTIVE
OVERVIEW FOR THE SEATTLE POLICE
DEPARTMENT USE OF TRACKING
DEVICES.
>> I MOVE THAT THE COMMITTEE
RECOMMEND THE PASSAGE.
>> SECOND.
>> IT'S BEEN MOVED AND SECONDED
TO RECOMMEND PASSAGE OF THE
BILL. THERE ARE THE TWO
AMENDMENTS EVER ABOUT US. WOULD
YOU PLEASE MOVE AMENDMENT ONE?
>> I MOVE AMENDMENT ONE TO
COUNCIL BILL 120504.
>> SECOND. OKAY, WOULD YOU --
LET'S PROCEED TO A VOTE ON
AMENDMENT ONE.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THANK YOU. AMENDMENT ONE IS
ADOPTED. THAT'S GO TO NUMBER
TWO.
>> MOVE AMENDMENT TWO TO COUNCI
BILL 120504.
>> SECOND.
>> ALL RIGHT, IT'S BEEN MOVED
AND SECONDED TO ADOPT AMENDMENT
TWO. LET'S CALL THE ROLL.
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON, AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, THE
MOTION CARRIES, AMENDMENT TWO I
ADOPTED, AND THE BILL IS BEFORE
US NOW. WILL THE CLERK PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL IF THERE ARE NO
FURTHER QUESTIONS?
>> COUNCILMEMBER STRAUSS.
>> YES.
>> COUNCILMEMBER HERBOLD.
>> YES.
>> CHAIR NELSON.
>> AYE.
>> THREE IN FAVOR.
>> OKAY, THE MOTION CARRIES, AN
THE RECOMMENDATION THE BILL
PASSES WILL BE TRANSFERRED TO
FULL COUNCIL COUNCIL ON THE
28th. BEFORE WE ADJOURN, I HAVE
SOME THANKS, BUT I NEED TO ALSO
REMIND FOLKS THAT WITH
RETROACTIVE TECHNOLOGIES, EVEN
IF THESE DO NOT PASS ON THE
28th, THE DEPARTMENT CAN
CONTINUE TO USE THESE
TECHNOLOGIES, AND THE REQUESTS
ARE REQUESTS NOT DIRECTIVES. SO
I JUST WANT TO THANK, THIS WAS
LOT OF WORK. THIS WENT MUCH MOR
QUICKLY THAN I ANTICIPATED
TODAY, SO I APPRECIATE
EVERYBODY'S EFFICIENCY. BUT
BEFORE WE GOT TO TODAY THERE WA
A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF STAFF
WORK ON THE PART OF THE SEATTLE
POLICE DEPARTMENT AND SEATTLE
I.T. SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
LEADING THE PUBLIC OUTREACH
PROCESS AS WELL AS STAFFING THE
WORK GROUP MEETINGS, AND
ANSWERING QUESTIONS. SO I JUST
WANT TO SAY THAT THAT IS, I DO
RECOGNIZE THAT IS A LOT OF
EFFORT. SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AND LISA, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
ALL THE WORK THAT YOU DID.
BECAUSE YOU WERE THERE
THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE PROCESS AS
WELL, AND YOU DID A LOT OF
EDUCATING OF ME AND MY STAFF
THROUGHOUT THIS WHOLE PROCESS.
AND FINALLY, I DO HAVE TO THANK
OUR CLERK, STEVEN. BECAUSE IN I
AN INCREDIBLY PAINSTAKING
PROCESS TO PUT ITEMS ON THE
AGENDA. THERE IS A LOT OF
MISTAKES THAT CAN BE MADE ALONG
THE WAY IN THE BACK END TO MAKE
SURE THAT THESE PIECES OF
LEGISLATION AND THE AMENDMENTS
ARE FULLY ACCESSIBLE. AND NOT
JUST APPEAR ON THE AGENDA, BUT
THAT THEY ARE ACCESSIBLE PRETTY
MUCH FOREVER. SO THANK YOU,
EVERYONE, FOR THE TEAM WORK. AN
I WILL OPEN IT UP FOR ADDITIONA
BUSINESS. OKAY. ALL RIGHT.
SEEING NONE, THIS CONCLUDES THE
FEBRUARY 22nd IMMEDIATING OF TH
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TECHNOLOGY
AND CITY LIGHT COMMITTEE
MEETING. OUR NEXT MEETING IS
SCHEDULED FOR WEDNESDAY, MARCH
8th, WHICH IS INTERNATIONAL
WOMEN'S DAY. MARCH 8th, AT 9:30
A.M. IT IS NOW 10:39. THIS
MEETING IS ADJOURNED.